J. Thaddeus Toad - Ty the Tasmania

Angus MacBadger - Knuckles

Rat - Sonic

Mole - Tails

Cyril Proudbottom - Lightning McQueen

Mr. Winky - Robotnik

The Weasels - Minions (Smash Bros.)

The Judge - Roy Snyder

The Prosecutor - Lionel Hutz

Policeman - Clancy Wiggum

Policemen - Springfield's Police Force

The Narrator for "The Wind in the Willows" segment - Himself

Ichabod Crane - Popeye

Katrina Van Tassel - Olive Oyl

Brom Bones - Bluto

Baltus Van Tassel - J. Wellington Wimpy

The Headless Horseman - Akuma

The Headless Horseman's Horse - Master Hand

The Townspeople - all King of Fighters Chars

Ichabod's Horse - Mater

Brom Bones' Horse - Chick Hicks

The Ladies That Ichabod Giving Singing Lessons To - Blossom, Bubbles & Buttercup

Sleepy Hollow Dogs - Snowpuff, Charfol, Sproot, Wott and Mermina

Crazy Lady - Bliss

The Narrator for "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow" segment - Himself